For the Very First Time

Corin Nemec

Michael

Cheryl Pollak

Mary Margaret

Mädchen Amick

Rhonda

Rebecca Cross

Roxy

Tim Griffin

Kenny Johnston

John

Donovan Leitch

Gerardo Mejía

Cassanova

David Sheinkopf

Goldstein

Deidre Hall

Mrs. O'Neil

Ernie Lively

Mr. O'Neil

Cristine Rose

Mrs. Allen

Joe Spano

Mr. Allen

David Hayward

Coach Hudson

Christian Hoff

Steven

Casey Sander

Buddy

J.P. Hubbell

Luke

Rick Podell

Mr. Goldstein

John Ingle

Father Talbot

No photo

Scott Curtis

Matthew

Eugene Lee

Charlie

No photo

Jenna Pangburn

Michelle

Sharon Clark

Kathy

No photo

Anita Ortega

Carmen

No photo

Sophia Delgado

Lia Cucaracha

Lilyan Chauvin

Sister Eugenia

No photo

Jennifer Gundy

Carol Lee

No photo

Ray Berrios

Priest

No photo

Rod Britt

Instructor

No photo

Liza Kumjian-Smith

Student (uncredited)